• Announcements
  • Contact
  • Documents
  • Events
  • Gov’t Achievements
  • UNC Councillors
  • Video Gallery
  • Volunteer
  • Home
  • News
    • Commentary
    • Letters
    • Press Releases
    • Speeches
    • Testimonies
  • About UNC
    • Political Leader
    • UNC Founder
    • UNC Natex
    • Meet The Candidates
  • Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Link
  • Live Stream
  • Youth Arm
  • The Checklist.
HEADLINES
Couva South Constituents Reject WASA “1 in 9 days” Water Supply
Opposition Leader sends condolences to Turkey and Syria after deadly earthquake
With 1000 Murders under his watch Opposition renew calls for Hinds removal
Opposition Leader: Armour cannot investigate himself
Armour Compromised Beyond Redemption
Opposition Leader: Double whammy for Reggie
Opposition Leader condemns Armour’s attack on Judge
Opposition Leader: Armour’s defense shameful, time for PNM to disappear
TANCOO: Government facilitating corruption
Opposition Leader: Faris and Armour must go now

Attorney Kiel Taklalsingh: Prime Minister’s defense rings hollow

Posted On 09 Jan 2023
By : Admin

Kiel Taklalsingh
Attorney At Law

1. “Constitution mandates this process”. I dealt with that in my previous post. Having the power to do something does not mean you should do it or that such action is constitutional. The convention has been to appoint persons who would be at least expected to act independently. This is perhaps why judges have been nominated and appointed in the past.

2. “Anonymous Vote” This again is a poor defense. Is the PM saying that he nominated Ms. Kangaloo thinking her nomination would be defeated? Or that members of the Govt would vote against the candidate he has publicly endorsed. Obviously not. His nomination as PM is expected to be successful. The problem is with his choice of candidate who has been ensconced in the PNM for many years and has actively advocated for the gospel of the PNM to be spread. Nothing is wrong with holding that view, the problem is putting someone in a position to spread that gospel within independent institutions or placing persons in those institutions with such a political agenda. The only inference to be made is that her exercise of power would be partisan and not beneficial to Service Commissions, EBC, Integrity Commission etc.

3. “Politicians have been made judges” or words to that effect. This, respectfully, is not persuasive reasoning; it is sophistry. Currently, judges are not selected by the PM, they are selected by the JLSC. Clearly, in the case of any particular judge who now serves, the JLSC was satisfied that the said judge was no longer in active politics or could discharge his/her functions independently. Can that honestly be said about Ms. Kangaloo? The JLSC has nothing to gain by selecting that person as a judge and so the population can trust that decision. On the other hand, the PM and his political party can benefit by decisions made by Ms. Kangaloo (such as EBC appointments) In any event, any litigant who feels a judge may be tainted by bias (political or not) can make an application for that judge to recuse himself. That application can be appealed to the Privy Council if necessary. Whenever a President Kangaloo appoints a member of the EBC or JLCS, there is no similar recourse for citizens.

4. Jwala Rambaran decision. I respectfully suggest the PM read the decision; he could obtain a copy from his minister of finance. The issue was one of natural justice. The constitution also did not explicitly require the cabinet to afford Mr. Rambaran an opportunity to be heard yet the decision was found unlawful. The fly in the ointment for Mrs. Kangaloo however is that such an important order should have been left for the substantive office holder, a former judge, who would have likely required adherence to Natural Justice prior to the termination order. The PM said she obtained legal advice before she made the order; that could only mean the decision was not ritualistic and required consideration, all the more reason for her not to have involved herself. The enthusiasm to facilitate the flawed process is a material matter which, whether the PM thinks so or not, is relevant to an assessment of Ms. Kangaloo’s fitness for office.

Additionally, the PM himself have made previous utterances on the matter of a serving president where he suggested that arrangements for the presidency should be reviewed to avoid active politicians. The logic to be extrapolated from such an argument is that the office, should as far as possible, be kept free of political appointees.

Unfortunately, he seems to have changed his position because it now benefits him to do so.

Kiel Taklalsingh
Attorney At Law

Post Views: 419

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • google-share
Previous Story

Opposition Leader: Rowley desperately shifting the goalposts over Presidency

Next Story

Tancoo: Government playing Russian roulette with our country and economy

News

Off

Couva South Constituents Reject WASA “1 in 9 days” Water Supply

Today, I reject every dishonest, disingenuous idea that the Water and Sewerage Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (WASA) had resumed a regular
Posted On 08 Feb 2023
Off

Opposition Leader sends condolences to Turkey and Syria after deadly earthquake

I am deeply saddened by the devastating loss of lives in Turkey and Syria following the earthquakes that struck both countries. Reports state
Posted On 06 Feb 2023
Off

With 1000 Murders under his watch Opposition renew calls for Hinds removal

Trinidad and Tobago has recorded the grim milestone of 1000 murders under Keith Rowley’s absurd appointee Fitzgerald Hinds. It was also the
Posted On 04 Feb 2023
Off

Opposition Leader: Armour cannot investigate himself

Armour’s competence and conduct have been called into question by two significant events: 1) The failure of the State to defend the malicious
Posted On 03 Feb 2023
Off

Armour Compromised Beyond Redemption

In the last two days, the country has been overloaded with information that points to one undeniable fact – Reginald Armour is compromised beyond
Posted On 03 Feb 2023
Off

Opposition Leader: Double whammy for Reggie

The judgment by the Third District Court of Appeal in the State of Florida, in the United States, confirming the disqualification of Attorney
Posted On 02 Feb 2023

Commentary

UNC SENATORS DEFENDED THE PARTY WELL TODAY

Today, the Opposition UNC Senators defended themselves and the Party well from the frivolous, anti-democratic motion by Senator Anthony Viera.
Posted On 22 Feb 2022

COVID WORKERS FIGHTING A WAR WITHOUT THEIR PROPER WEAPONS

We congratulate Kamla Persad-Bissessar on her success in forcing the Government to conduct an inquiry into the handling of covid. We take this
Posted On 20 Feb 2022

ROWLEY, WHERE ART THOU? WHY ARE YOU HIDING IN ST. ANN’S WHILE THE CITIZENS OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO SUFFERED 12 HOURS OF EXTENDED OUTAGE?

For 12 hours, and more in some places, the entire island of Trinidad experienced a power outage, beginning after lunch and plunging the entire
Posted On 17 Feb 2022

UNC WORKING IN PRINCES TOWN AND COUVA/TABAQUITE/TALPARO

We don’t often hear about what our local government bodies are doing for residents. Henry Awong, Chairman of the Couva/Tabaquite/Talparo
Posted On 10 Feb 2022

WHATEVER HAPPENED TO KEITH ROWLEY’S INEZ GATE ISSUE?

Remember Inez Gate? What is the Integrity Commission doing about the fact that Keith Rowley as Prime Minister did not fill in the required
Posted On 03 Feb 2022

Letters

Seek a fresh mandate

I recently read in one of the daily newspapers that Minister of National Security Fitzgerald Hinds said that 70% of society wants to see him
Posted On 27 Dec 2022

Don’t Blame God for Rowley’s Dotishness

Prime Minister Keith Rowley at the PNM convention on December 4, 2022, announces a National Day of Prayer. He said the country must come together
Posted On 16 Dec 2022

Keith Rowley has betrayed the sanctity of Parliament

Dear Editor, The revelation by the Commissioner of Police that the emails which Keith Rowley, then Opposition Leader read in our nations
Posted On 19 Jul 2019

T&T owes Kamla a debt of gratitude

Kamla Persad-Bissessar did what many were not expecting… she and her MPs voted unanimously with the Government to ensure passage of the Civil
Posted On 09 Apr 2019

Unity and Coalition are different things

Opposition Leader Kamla Persad Bissessar has faced some stinging criticism relative to her declaration at the UNC’s National Assembly that the
Posted On 01 Feb 2019

Press Releases

Off

PADARATH: RIC closed door consultations is a travesty to the process

Princes Town MP, Barry Padarath says he is deeply concerned and troubled with the Regulated Industries Commission attempt to conceal the views of
Posted On 06 Feb 2023
Off

Couva North MP launches National Health Initiative “Celebrating Wellness: A Healthier T&T”

On Wednesday February 1st, 2023, the Constituency of Couva North celebrated another landmark achievement, when Couva North MP Ravi Ratiram
Posted On 02 Feb 2023
Off

Foreign countries choose ceremonial heads with track records, does Christine this bill?

While many Commonwealth countries have ceremonial Heads of State (HOS) who are visible symbols of national unity and who have life long track
Posted On 16 Jan 2023
Off

SENATOR NAKHID: Government not Transparent about Affairs of our Children

Having seen an editorial in the Trinidad Express concerning Minister Ayana Webster Roy’s inexplicable decision to allow the Margaret Kistow Home
Posted On 16 Jan 2023
Off

Balisier House Must be Kept Separately from President’s House

Prime Minister Rowley has again disappointed the nation, with his selection of Senator Christine Kangaloo as his personally recruited
Posted On 14 Jan 2023

Speeches

Tancoo: calls on Imbert to have a heart and indemnify the population

Today we come to you to shine some light on a very worrying development that has happened in the past few days. I am sure many of you saw or
Posted On 08 Sep 2021

Rowley’s Mad Power Grab in Tobago

My friends, we are seeing a government that is in freefall – in every single sector. Health, National Security, the business sector. And what
Posted On 16 Feb 2021

Presentation of UNC general election candidates 2020

T&T family! UNC family! It is my absolute pleasure to speak with you today, as we get ready for the sweeping victory that is to come on
Posted On 19 Jul 2020

Kamla: My vision is to build an intelligent nation

“ON THE BALLOT” UNC VIRTUAL MEETING (June 25, 2020) Introduction Good evening and thank you for joining us once again as we continue to set the
Posted On 26 Jun 2020

MNF – Kamla: There is hope

Introduction Good evening T&T! Good evening UNC family!  It is good to be back! 2020 we are ready to rumble! Are you ready? Even though it’s
Posted On 11 Mar 2020
Copyright © - 2022 United National Congress