• Announcements
  • Contact
  • Documents
  • Events
  • Gov’t Achievements
  • UNC Councillors
  • Video Gallery
  • Volunteer
  • Home
  • News
    • Commentary
    • Letters
    • Press Releases
    • Speeches
    • Testimonies
  • About UNC
    • Political Leader
    • UNC Founder
    • UNC Natex
    • Meet The Candidates
  • Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Link
  • Live Stream
  • Youth Arm
  • The Checklist.
HEADLINES
Rowley reintroduces UNC programs eight years after destroying them
Attorney: RIC cannot dim the lights on freedom of expression
OPPOSITION LEADER: Armour Will be Remembered as the Worst AG in History
PADARATH: RIC Running From The People, Aborts Consultation
Tancoo: Why the Secrecy Rohan?
Paray Condemns PM Rowley Distasteful Portrayal of MP Charles
PM’S REPULSIVE PORTRAYAL OF MP CHARLES
THE PEOPLE WANT WATER
MOONILAL: TTTI DAMN FARSE AND OUTTA PLACE
OPPOSITION LEADER: AG Armour’s Incompetence Cost Taxpayers Over 60 Million Dollars

Opposition Leader condemns Armour’s attack on Judge

Posted On 02 Feb 2023
By : Admin

Attorney General Armour’s pathetic press conference to explain why he and his sidekick Faris Al-Rawi failed to defend the claim for malicious prosecution brought by the men accused of kidnapping and murdering businesswoman Vindra Naipaul-Coolman has opened a pandora’s box for the PNM.

In the botched attempt to defend his gross incompetence, he overlooked certain facts that expose his lies, deception, and political hypocrisy. A careful reading of the judgment, delivered by Master Martha Alexander, reveals that not only was the AG represented by a distinguished legal team from his Ministry but it was led by Ms Karen Reid Ballantyne who is now a High Court Judge.

The judgment of the High Court records the following:

Para. 3 – “…The present matter, therefore, was a substantial one that the defendant chose neither to defend nor to call any evidence save to appear at the assessment to be heard on quantum.”

Para. 19 – “In the above regard, therefore, the court could not accept or agree with the submissions of counsel for the defendant that it should find collusion and collaboration between the experts and claimants because of the similarity of diagnosis

…

Where claimants are subjected to the same horrendous prison conditions and the same mental torture and humiliation, how could these be described differently to satisfy a defendant’s suspicion of collusion? This court has no doubt that given the exposure to the inhumane prison conditions and lengthy incarceration, the claimants would have suffered psychological injury, which manifested in different ways in some of the claimants. This is not an issue of “cut and paste” evidence or “a dishonest collaboration designed to increase the Claimants’ claims for damages,” as alleged by the defendant’s counsel in her submissions. In fact, the witness statements might have similar contents, based on their similar experiences, but these were expressed differently, with some claimants focusing on the extreme heat, foul smells and cramped, unsanitary conditions and how those affected their sinuses and other health issues. These arguments of the defendant’s counsel go way beyond the pale of what could be supported by the evidence before the court.”

Para. 20 – “Medical illnesses or diseases could manifest with similarity of symptoms in different persons; so the argument of counsel for the defendant that questioned how all claimants had the same diagnosis was baseless.

Para. 32 – “There was no comparator provided, which approximated the exact length of prosecution and deprivation of liberty, on serious charges, as in the present case. For their nine years of failed prosecution, the claimants sought general damages of TT$3.5 million each; whilst the defendant recommended that each be paid TT$1.2 million. The court was particularly interested in the defendant’s rationale for its suggested quantum, as the claimants had led evidence on which they sought to justify their substantial claims but the defendant did not. However, counsel for the defendant provided comparators on the low end of the spectrum of awards, without making any comparative justifications for the suggested individual awards. Further, the factual context of the defendant’s comparators were so obviously distinguishable that it was difficult to find any comparative relevance.”

It would be a serious breach of the Code of Ethics for any attorney to fully participate in a trial to assess damages without a file. This is so because Attorneys must act on instructions and based on the documents that were filed in Court. It would be a serious act of misconduct on the part of Ms Reid-Ballantyne if she, as counsel, argued a case on behalf of the AG without having the file.

The $20M award of damages was not a consent order made pursuant to an agreement between the parties. The AG’s legal team led by Ms Reid-Ballantyne actively opposed and defended the assessment of damages.

The AG has therefore cast a most serious aspersion on the character and competence of a sitting Judge of the High Court who is meant to deliver justice to our citizens. Judges must possess a high level of personal and professional integrity and impeccable character.

This attack on Madam Justice Reid Ballantyne’s character is a serious one that could bring the administration of justice into disrepute. PNM trolls are already poking fun by rhetorically asking “what if Her Ladyship writes judgments in cases, she is doing without a court file?” It is therefore imperative that Madam Justice Reid Ballantyne clears the air on whether she had the file in her possession when she represented the State at the trial of the assessment of damages.

The AG said they only received the file two days ago after Minister Young requested same from the Judiciary. If he has lied on Madam Justice Reid Ballantyne, and she did in fact have the file in her possession as the judgment suggests, and participated in the trial, on this basis the AG must immediately apologise to the learned Judge and immediately tender his resignation in shame and disgrace.

We, therefore, call upon Madam Justice Reid Ballantyne to issue a statement to clear the air on this matter. Her character, competence, and integrity have been called into question by the AG. Silence is not an option in the face of the 20-million-dollar judgment that has caused legitimate public outrage.

We wish to make it abundantly clear that we have no reason to doubt that Madam Justice Reid Ballantyne performed her duties in a professional and competent manner. It is clear from the Court’s judgment that she made submissions to the Court and could only have done so if she had the file. We consider the suggestion to the contrary by the AG to be nothing more than reckless political damage control and an attempt to save his own skin. Justice Reid Ballantyne’s track record speaks for itself – she is a former Solicitor General of Grenada and a former Assistant Solicitor General of Trinidad and Tobago.

We also call upon the Honourable Chief Justice to clarify whether the Court issued the relevant notices to the AG of the date, time, and place of each hearing in this matter. This is in fact the established practice and procedure, and this would also expose the AG’s lie that the file went missing and the State knew nothing about the progress of this matter.

If, as we suspect, these notifications were sent to the AG by the Court, the AG must apologise to the Judiciary for casting aspersions on the administration of justice. Surely if notifications were sent, the AG was under an obligation to retrieve the file and prepare for the hearing of which he had been notified by the Court. To do otherwise, would be dangerous incompetence and misconduct for which he must be held responsible. He is the titular head of the Bar and has brought the legal profession into disrepute.

The AG cannot disassociate and distance himself from this matter. As he himself pointed out, in 2018 Al-Rawi wrote a memo to rectify perceived weaknesses in the systems for accountability in the Office of the Attorney General. Having been aware of this, what did the AG do to ensure that there is a proper system in place to ensure that there is transparency, accountability, and good public administration?

As the Minister in charge, the buck stops with him and he must do the decent and honourable thing and tender his resignation forthwith, in accordance with the conventions of the Westminster System of Parliamentary Government.

Kamla Persad-Bissessar, SC, MP
Leader of the Opposition

2nd February 2023

Post Views: 217

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • google-share
Previous Story

Opposition Leader: Armour’s defense shameful, time for PNM to disappear

Next Story

Opposition Leader: Double whammy for Reggie

News

Off

Rowley reintroduces UNC programs eight years after destroying them

Eight years after needlessly and spitefully shutting down the programs the former UNC Government put in place to transform our education system
Posted On 22 Mar 2023
Off

Attorney: RIC cannot dim the lights on freedom of expression

As a lifelong resident of Chaguanas, I attended the public consultation on proposed increased electricity rates held by the Regulated Industries
Posted On 17 Mar 2023
Off

OPPOSITION LEADER: Armour Will be Remembered as the Worst AG in History

No one could have imagined how inept Reginald Armour would turn out to be as the replacement for the disastrous Faris Al-Rawi. No citizen takes
Posted On 16 Mar 2023
Off

PADARATH: RIC Running From The People, Aborts Consultation

Shadow Minister for Public Utilities, MP Barry Padarath, who has been very vocal about the manner in which the RIC is handling a proposed
Posted On 16 Mar 2023
Off

Tancoo: Why the Secrecy Rohan?

Oropouche West MP Dave Tancoo has accused Minister Rohan Sinanan of an “obscene and arrogant insult” to the 26,000 taxpayers living
Posted On 15 Mar 2023
Off

Paray Condemns PM Rowley Distasteful Portrayal of MP Charles

EVEN by the low public speaking standards he has set for himself, Prime Minister Dr. Keith Rowley’s depiction of my colleague Rodney Charles is
Posted On 11 Mar 2023

Commentary

UNC SENATORS DEFENDED THE PARTY WELL TODAY

Today, the Opposition UNC Senators defended themselves and the Party well from the frivolous, anti-democratic motion by Senator Anthony Viera.
Posted On 22 Feb 2022

COVID WORKERS FIGHTING A WAR WITHOUT THEIR PROPER WEAPONS

We congratulate Kamla Persad-Bissessar on her success in forcing the Government to conduct an inquiry into the handling of covid. We take this
Posted On 20 Feb 2022

ROWLEY, WHERE ART THOU? WHY ARE YOU HIDING IN ST. ANN’S WHILE THE CITIZENS OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO SUFFERED 12 HOURS OF EXTENDED OUTAGE?

For 12 hours, and more in some places, the entire island of Trinidad experienced a power outage, beginning after lunch and plunging the entire
Posted On 17 Feb 2022

UNC WORKING IN PRINCES TOWN AND COUVA/TABAQUITE/TALPARO

We don’t often hear about what our local government bodies are doing for residents. Henry Awong, Chairman of the Couva/Tabaquite/Talparo
Posted On 10 Feb 2022

WHATEVER HAPPENED TO KEITH ROWLEY’S INEZ GATE ISSUE?

Remember Inez Gate? What is the Integrity Commission doing about the fact that Keith Rowley as Prime Minister did not fill in the required
Posted On 03 Feb 2022

Letters

Seek a fresh mandate

I recently read in one of the daily newspapers that Minister of National Security Fitzgerald Hinds said that 70% of society wants to see him
Posted On 27 Dec 2022

Don’t Blame God for Rowley’s Dotishness

Prime Minister Keith Rowley at the PNM convention on December 4, 2022, announces a National Day of Prayer. He said the country must come together
Posted On 16 Dec 2022

Keith Rowley has betrayed the sanctity of Parliament

Dear Editor, The revelation by the Commissioner of Police that the emails which Keith Rowley, then Opposition Leader read in our nations
Posted On 19 Jul 2019

T&T owes Kamla a debt of gratitude

Kamla Persad-Bissessar did what many were not expecting… she and her MPs voted unanimously with the Government to ensure passage of the Civil
Posted On 09 Apr 2019

Unity and Coalition are different things

Opposition Leader Kamla Persad Bissessar has faced some stinging criticism relative to her declaration at the UNC’s National Assembly that the
Posted On 01 Feb 2019

Press Releases

Off

Charles calls for investigation into funding of Balisier House

Following TTPS, CTU and FIU inaction on this matter, Charles has written to Transparency International requesting their assistance in demanding
Posted On 17 Mar 2023
Off

PADARATH: RIC Now Openly Political, Their PNM Petticoat is Showing

Shadow Minister of Public Utilities, MP Barry Padarath has rejected the public utterances of the RIC, particularly the Chairman Dawn Callender
Posted On 17 Mar 2023
Off

INDARSINGH: Minister Gadsby-Dolly Denying Students of Couva West a Proper Education

Today, I am calling on the Minister of Education, Dr. the Honourable Nyan Gadsby- Dolly to stop neglecting the students, parents and teachers at
Posted On 17 Mar 2023
Off

MP Tancoo Launches Petition Following Government’s Failure to Provide Reliable Water Supply

Following demands for the Constituency of Oropouche West, MP Tancoo has launched a petition demanding that the government takes urgent action to
Posted On 16 Mar 2023
0

PM’S REPULSIVE PORTRAYAL OF MP CHARLES

EVEN by the low public speaking standards he has set for himself, Prime Minister Dr. Keith Rowley’s depiction of my colleague Rodney Charles is
Posted On 11 Mar 2023

Speeches

Tancoo: calls on Imbert to have a heart and indemnify the population

Today we come to you to shine some light on a very worrying development that has happened in the past few days. I am sure many of you saw or
Posted On 08 Sep 2021

Rowley’s Mad Power Grab in Tobago

My friends, we are seeing a government that is in freefall – in every single sector. Health, National Security, the business sector. And what
Posted On 16 Feb 2021

Presentation of UNC general election candidates 2020

T&T family! UNC family! It is my absolute pleasure to speak with you today, as we get ready for the sweeping victory that is to come on
Posted On 19 Jul 2020

Kamla: My vision is to build an intelligent nation

“ON THE BALLOT” UNC VIRTUAL MEETING (June 25, 2020) Introduction Good evening and thank you for joining us once again as we continue to set the
Posted On 26 Jun 2020

MNF – Kamla: There is hope

Introduction Good evening T&T! Good evening UNC family!  It is good to be back! 2020 we are ready to rumble! Are you ready? Even though it’s
Posted On 11 Mar 2020
Copyright © - 2022 United National Congress